Making the Internet safer for your family

2008 November 16
by David Ker

Note: The original title of this post was “In which Lingamish searches for porn, girls and xxx.”

image Our family is slowly habituating to the US and its oddities. We continue to be shocked and amazed by the variety in the grocery stores. If only we could transport the smallest convenience store in the most podunk US town to our village in Africa we would feel rich beyond measure.

We haven’t figured out what to do with TV. I love football and HGTV. The Extreme Foods show with Andrew Whatsisname was fun for a while but then it started reminding me too much of life in Africa. Speaking of eating, I’ve gained a respectable 20 pounds since arriving in the US four months ago. I’ve never had a love handle before and am quite proud of it (No pictures, sorry).

Living in Africa we never needed things like parental controls and SPAM blockers because our Internet was so slow and so seldom connected that it was literally impossible for anything malicious or prurient to get on to our computers.

All that’s changed now. We have four laptops in the house. High-speed wireless. And someone in every room accessing one thing or another on the Internet.

So the question comes up: What can we do to protect little eyes? And big eyes as well! At the same time I discovered that an acquaintance was allowing their family to browse the web without any kind of parental controls. I promised to look into it and let me tell you it is complicated. There are controls you can put on your computer. There are controls for your browser. There are accountability systems that send lists of your URLs visited to a chosen “accountability partner.” There are complete software packages that will actually strip out naughty words and replace them with stars.

It is not an exaggeration to say that this is a scary world we live in. When I was a kid the only way I could see porn was because one of my friends had discovered his Dad’s stash of dirty magazines. Nowadays any kid that types “girl,” “bikini” or “sex” into his web browser is instantly sucked into a cesspool of filth. Let me talk frankly with you. Boys are very curious about these things. Way beyond that. The hormones and the physical drives that kick in during adolescence are insane. So I don’t think you’re going to stop boys from thinking about such things. But I do think you can hopefully limit the fuel for their fantasizing to bra ads in the newspaper rather than hard core porn sites on the web.

So I went in search of something to stem the tide of junk on our computers so that hopefully our kids could use the Internet without danger.

Kids up to age 12

image The solution I ended up with for my kids was Glubble. This is a Firefox add-on that essentially hijacks your FireFox browser and turns it into a kid-friendly browser that only allows kids to visit pre-approved sites. If they try to visit a site that hasn’t been approved by the Glubble folks, it is blocked but they can send a request to their parent or guardian requesting permission to view it.

My kids have had a blast with this. It has thousands of sites with games and silly games and lots of games and… games… you get the picture.

Coupled with this I set up the Content Advisor in Windows to only accept rated sites. This essentially locks down Internet Explorer with a password that the parent supplies so they can only use FireFox.

Teens and Adults

image

I really struggled to find something that would work for teens and adults. There are solutions for Windows or Apple. And Internet Explorer or FireFox. There are many commercial options like Covenant Eyes. But I wanted something free. And simple.

I was looking for something that did the following:

  1. Blocks known objectionable content
  2. Keeps a log of sites visited on that computer
  3. Isn’t browser or OS dependent

I was completely stumped until I turned to the homeschoolers’ forum. My wife has access to the Sonlight Forum and it is full of homeschool moms manically trading messages about the preferred history book for Core 3 and what to do about a child who refuses to do handwriting, etc. I searched for “internet filter” and came upon a long thread mentioning many of the programs I had already tried as well as something called K9 Web Protection.

Turns out K9 is terrific. It’s free. You install it on the computer and it keeps track of sites visited and also blocks objectionable content.

Once I found this I sat down with my wife and put it to the test. We searched for “porn.” We searched for “girls” and “xxx.” In some cases Google simply blocked these because of the SafeSearch settings we had selected for Google. But it would still bring up results like this:

Maxim Magazine’s Girls of Maxim section featuring hot girls and the most beautiful women.

If you tried to click on it (Hilary clicked while I averted my gaze) it simply brought up a message saying, “K9 Web Protection Alert: Category Blocked.” Then this attempted visit was logged in a place that only the administrator could access with a password.

We ended up installing it on all our computers and are trying it out. It is also available in beta for the Mac. About the only thing that we changed was to have K9 block Google Images and always accept lingamish.com. 8)

There isn’t really a way to protect your children (or husband as the case may be) from looking at salacious content on the Internet. Sometimes you will stumble on things but I think a system like K9 will drastically reduce the “stumbling blocks.” For example, Hilary and I searched for “bikini” and Google returned a result for Flickr showing girls posing in bikinis. But without K9, such a search would have been one click away from hard core porn.

General comments

I really think that it’s important to try to be open about this stuff and include the people we’re trying to “police” in the process. So I’ve been explaining to our young kids why we’re putting controls on the computer (without giving too many details). In the case of our friends with the teens I encouraged them to include the teens in setting up the software and controls on their computers and then Mom or Dad can change the password later and perhaps meet with the kids once a week to talk about “results” or whenever suspicious activity is taking place.

I’m very happy about Glubble as a way of creating a safe way for my small kids to explore the Internet. When they get older they’ll probably want less restriction and a product like K9 might help them to explore without being led astray.

Links:

What about you? What are you doing to protect your kids and yourself from the unseemly side of the Internet?


Previous post: Parental Controls for FireFox and IE7

21 Responses
  1. 2008 November 17

    Thanks for the tip, David. I don’t use IE any more, but this does look good – free is always good. I think I’ll give it a go.

  2. 2008 November 17

    Would you believe that ProCon is blocking my access to K9’s site?

  3. 2008 November 17
    Caleb permalink

    I used to use bsafe.com but it slowed everything down and was a pain to add and change sites that were blocked that shouldn’t have been (perhaps like lingamish.com :) … I think I may try both k9 and glubble.

    Thanks

  4. 2008 November 17

    Mike, let me know about your experiences.

    Caleb, K9 slows things down as well. But you can approve sites that you commonly visit (like this one) and that will speed things up for a particular site. K9 blocks YouTube outright so you have to authorize a temporary visit to that site (15 minutes) if you want to visit it occasionally but in general want to stay away from there.

  5. 2008 November 18

    this is good good stuff. We need this and I’m over to K9 now.

    ..

    ..

    ..

    However, as someone who would prefer (if the church was strong enough to deal with it) to introduce myself as “Hi, I’m John, I’m a pornaholic.” I’d like to say that this is only one tool in the armour. Nothing beats the deliverance of God’s applied grace. If anyone wants a friend as they battle their way out of the porn maze, send me an email.

  6. 2008 November 18

    Thanks, man. One of the reasons I posted on the topic is that no one was posting on it… And we’ve had friends and their children destroyed/damaged by Internet porn and online relationships. I believe it destroys relationships and also enslaves people who otherwise would be free to build God’s kingdom.

  7. 2008 November 18

    For the moment we have the ultimate deterrent: dial-up internet! :-)

    I never needed its internet filtering aspects, but I had a great experience with KidWatch Time Control which allows one to limit the amount of time the computer or certain programs are used.

  8. 2008 November 18

    Another tool is simply looking at the history on your browser. A savvy kid will clear the history but that’s usually evidence that something’s up. Just communicating with our kids means a lot don’t you think?

    K9 can be set to block very little but still keep a log which is helpful for monitoring long term what’s being visited.

  9. 2008 November 18

    You should really check out Safe Eyes. Rated #1 internet filter, and with reason. Find it here:

    http://www.internetsafety.com/

  10. 2008 November 18
    Jon Beutler permalink

    Nice Title David! Safe Eyes does look good, but $50/year is a bit steep.

  11. 2008 November 19

    For the record, Jon and I tried to install the Mac Beta for K9 on his computer and it didn’t work. Yet one more reason to avoid that tempting Apple…

  12. 2008 November 20

    Let me tell you about my recent search for internet pornography.

    I recently tried to find out what “visceral clutch” meant by googling it. This resulted in me finding the excellent journalism of one Antonello Gambotto, who writes very well about the effects of pornography. It’s very well informed, and she’s a talented writer, too.

  13. 2008 November 21

    I personally like Open DNS – http://www.opendns.com/

    It’s FREE with NO installation. One of the many nice things about Open DNS is that you can set up your router and all of your computers will be filtered.

    VERY nice.

  14. 2008 November 24
    Josiah Kane permalink

    Thanks a lot! I have a simpler solution at my fingertips. limit internet usage to British Library computers. Not only did the computer knock me off as soon as is saw the word Pornography etc, it would not even let me get back on to read the other posts!

  15. 2008 November 29
    Josiah Kane permalink

    “Another tool is simply looking at the history on your browser. A savvy kid will clear the history but that’s usually evidence that something’s up.” As you will no doubt be aware any sort of computer info that wants to survive a shut down needs to be stored in a file. Might not a “savy kid,” many of whom are apparently better at computers than their parents eliminate a single record? (for non-computer geeks a record is a small section of a large file, like in a database, that covers a single object. )

  16. 2008 December 1
    Josiah Kane permalink

    Ooops, my mistake. The browser history is stored in seperate internet shortcut files (search for “history” or “Lingamish” in C:/Documents and settings and you will get there very fast indeed) The bad news is that this makes it even easier to take out one entry! Worse, you can even open the History and delete the same files as you can look at! (right click;delete) Isn’t it scary what you might not know about.

  17. 2008 December 1
    Josiah Kane permalink

    And one last security hole that you have left is one that does not yet exist. Within second I found a site comparing the 10 best internet browsers. What if one of them were downloaded without your knowing(as long as they dont share files with firefox or IE, there is nothing to stop them being tucked away in an obscure folder). Imagine the holes that would dig. I guess it is just as well you aren’t my dad, or Lingamish would have an “I surrender” by now. (that’s your cue.)

  18. 2008 December 1

    Again, I’m not trying to lock out hormonal 14 year olds who are determined to be naughty. Just regular controls to add a semblance of safety to our computer. And even what you’re proposing would be logged by a system like K9. If you are really sneaking past controls on your computer to look at inappropriate content I suggest you talk it over with your Mum and Dad.

  19. 2008 December 1
    Josiah Kane permalink

    Boo Hoo. You blew my cover. I just had a conversation going with Peter Kirk over burying kids, and you reveal my age! Anyway I am not sneaking past virtual nightguards to next doors virtual attic to look at their dad’s virtual dirty magazine. If I were, would I reveal my most precious secrets, not only to such a crazy hippoaholic but to everyone with a modem? I merely want to point out that a semblence of safety is dangerous indeed. The raging tides of hormones can be held at bay, and indeed usefully channeled, by a sturdy dam, but a rope floating on the surface with nothing beneath?

    Actually internet porn is an anomily to me-I thought that Computers were the only things that can replace women in a lad’s life! They have certainly done so for me.

  20. 2008 December 1
    Josiah Kane permalink

    Woops, I forgot to mention, By the same logic as I used earlier, K9 must also store it’s info in a file. Are you really safe? Try cutting the modem, uninstalling IE and firefox, smashing the screen(a blind man could walk into a girl’s showers without worry), hiring a hacker to destroy all internet porn sites on the planet, or giving up.

  21. 2008 December 1

    Josiah, K9 could store its info in the registry. But I’m sure you’ve worked out how to hack that. Yes, I’m sure you’re right, the battle of parents against teens is unwinnable by heavy guns. So how about using a little father-son friendship and trust? (OK, I know it’s about daughters too, but the easy way to stop their online addictions, to shopping, is to lock away your credit cards.)

Comments are closed for this entry.